For many people, nothing says Christmas like the smell of fresh evergreen.  Others would never dream of having a live tree. (I love a live tree, but I come from a family of folks who are allergic to pine.  A live Christmas tree would mean a holiday season of hives and labored breathing.  More Bah Humbug than Ho Ho Ho.)  Environmental activists may consider a potted evergreen that can be planted outside after the holiday. 

If you haven’t decided what sort of tree you’ll have this year, here are some things to consider:

• Cost:  An artificial tree requires a larger initial expenditure (unless you were very smart and bought one at the after-Christmas sales last year.)  However, a quality artificial tree will last for several years if stored properly.  On the other hand, many community groups sponsor Christmas tree sales, so you know that your money is aiding a good cause.
• Maintenance: A live tree must be watered regularly for the entire time it is in your house.  Without regular watering, the tree will dry out quickly, turning brown and beginning to drop its needles.  (Your vacuum cleaner will not like picking them up.)  A dry tree is a major fire hazard, especially given the likely proximity of hot lights and candles.  On the other hand, I have seen properly watered trees last into April.  If you will be away from your home for several days during the holiday season, you should either choose an artificial tree or take your tree down before departing.
• After Christmas:  When it’s time to take the tree down, you’ll need a place to store an artificial tree.  Most tree boxes are too large for a closet, so you’ll need an attic, basement, or other storage area.  Many cities offer disposal of live Christmas trees, turning them into mulch for spring flower beds.
• Atmosphere:  Live trees win this one hands down.  NOTHING smells like a live evergreen.  To me, the combination of cinnamon and pine is the smell of Christmas.  If you choose an artificial tree, you may want to enhance the atmosphere with a fresh wreath or garland.  If live pine isn’t practical for you, pine scented potpourri or a pine scented candle can help a little. If you go the potpourri or candle route, it’s not the time to pinch pennies.  Buy the best quality you can afford.  It could mean the difference between a house that smells like a pine forest and a house that smells like a taxi with a car deodorizer hanging from the rear view mirror.  (Try several votive-sized candles to determine the best quality brand before purchasing larger candles.  The most expensive isn’t always the best quality.)

If you love a live tree, indulge yourself.  Personally, I’d rather have a live tree with nothing but lights and homemade decorations than a fancy artificial tree.